I'm not a huge fan of mayonnaise. First of all, it's hard to spell. Secondly, I prefer mustard. I do, however, recognize its place in my culinary and sometimes medicinal world. Did you or a loved one ever spend the night wearing Hellmann's and a shower cap?
The dictionary states that a condiment is a "substance" used to flavor or complement food. I don't entirely agree. Sometimes I choose to eat a particular food simply because I feel like having ketchup. In other words, I think that food is a stage in which to celebrate the condiment.
As you may remember, during high school I worked as a sandwich maker and waitress at a local deli. It was there I realized that people are fanatical about their condiments. This concept dawned on me when one of our regulars ordered a bologna and cheese sandwich on white bread, mayo on the cheese side, mustard on the bologna side. WHAT?!
You can tell a lot of thought went into that request and the sandwich played second fiddle to the condiments that allegedly complemented it.
That brings me to today's challenge. To get in the mood, I turned on Itunes and cranked up Bill Conti's Going the Distance. I'm a Philadelphian and any competition always turns my thoughts to Rocky.
When I first thought of the Miracle Whip/Hellmann's challenge, I considered conducting a survey by making a couple of dishes and asking my family and friends to taste them. I still might do that but for today, I decided that, since I'm the Loco Diner, it is my opinion that matters. To showcase both products, I settled on a mayo must: boiled ham and American cheese on toasted white bread paired with Herr's Ruffles and a Diet Coke.
I opened the Miracle Whip and got my jumbo jar of Hellmann's out of the refrigerator (sorry, MW, I didn't want to make too big of an investment just yet.)
I judged the products on aroma, appearance, spreadability, taste and a bonus category. I first took in the aroma of each product and tasted them individually on spoons. This was difficult for me since, as I said, I'm not a mayo lover. I do think that fact makes me a fairer judge.
Both products were easily distinguishable by sight and fragrance.
The Miracle Whip was much whiter than its counterpart and, upon inspection, you could see flecks of the spices in it. The aroma was sweet and lemony. It reminded me a lot of a prepared tartar sauce.
The Hellmann's was a buttery yellow color. I mostly noticed the vinegar when I took in the aroma. The smell just triggered mayonnaise in my mind but, to be fair, this is my brand of choice.
As for the taste, the most prominent flavor in the Miracle Whip was the sweetness. It reminded me a lot of sweet pickles. The texture was smooth whereas the Hellmann's was richer. As for the taste, Hellmann's first punch was salt followed by vinegar.
While I felt like I had to taste both products individually, I think the sandwich test is the most important. I toasted the bread, cut it in half and made two individual sandwiches. I'd like to mention here that one of the most notable differences in the two products is that Miracle Whip is significantly creamier than Hellmann's to look at. Hellmanns appears lumpy while Miracle Whip looks more like a sauce. This difference was easily seen when spreading the two products onto the sandwich halves.
I tried the Miracle Whip half first. It was good. There was a definite sweetness that came through. This sweetness was enhanced when I added the "bonus" category. I like to add chips to my sandwich and the sweetness played nicely off of the salty chips.
after the first bite, I added Herrs Ruffles
The Hellmann's half was good too. As in the other categories, there was a definite difference. I feel that the Hellman's definitely enhanced the flavor of the sandwich but took a more behind-the-scenes role. You notice the ham and the cheese and it's pleasant but you might not know why. I think the why would be the Hellmann's.
I guess the bottom line is that these are two entirely different products. It comes down to what you like. Miracle Whip is center stage. If I had to pick an analogy, I'd call it a diva. It wants to be noticed and will be. Hellmann's fills the role of a good director, you don't see him but you know he's there by the quality of the work in front of you.
I'm not finished with the Miracle Whip/Hellmann's show down. I plan on trying Miracle Whip in other dishes and seeing how it works or changes them. I have to go. Since I made lunch my afternoon's activity, it's time to start dinner.
To be continued...
I guess the bottom line is that these are two entirely different products. It comes down to what you like. Miracle Whip is center stage. If I had to pick an analogy, I'd call it a diva. It wants to be noticed and will be. Hellmann's fills the role of a good director, you don't see him but you know he's there by the quality of the work in front of you.
I'm not finished with the Miracle Whip/Hellmann's show down. I plan on trying Miracle Whip in other dishes and seeing how it works or changes them. I have to go. Since I made lunch my afternoon's activity, it's time to start dinner.
To be continued...